Do Not Pay Magical Teachers!

[Faria]

I am here advocating for the total disregard of anybody involved in paid occult mentorship.
It's a parasitic industry fueled by social media.

I make this appeal to people who consider themselves students, and those who consider these gurus as peers.
I do not believe that the occult community benefits from this model of growth.

If you are a magician with something to say, write a book, teach people, do as you please; but if you start padding your income with "How to Do Magic" classes, I'm going to regard you as far, far less of a magician than if you weren't offering that. Those who can, do.

"You think everything should be free!"

No. I think people who teach practical magic - who would otherwise be unremarkable as magicians - should be regarded as suspicious at best and more likely as con-men.

"People pay to learn all sorts of things!"

In most fields of human activity, the activity is tangible and the teaching is demonstrable. Nothing like that exists for magic. From an objective point of view there is absolutely no way to tell the difference between who is totally full of crap and who is solid gold in the field of magic.

Sure, learn the history and whatnot, the literature, the tradition, and pay for your academic education in those things. I am not against paying for knowledge.

But occult practitioner gurus are different. They propose to teach something effective, useful, and something for which they profess competence that you could use. So does a martial arts instructor, music instructor, or dance instructor. Pay those people, and anyone can see that something real is being taught. That doesn't exist for magic teachings.

Nobody with better things to do is going to think it's worth their time to sell Zoom classes to goobers from the Internet and then babystep them through whatever they concocted as a babystepping program.

And realize I am not here saying that anything you might get from these gurus is bad or false, although some of it will be for sure. And if you have doubts, for sure, go ahead and pay, and you will see what I mean here. I think the majority of these functions will lead you down a dead-end path, something that was ultimately drafted as a product for sale. That tells you someone got a good sense of the literature and the market for it. But people who connect with real magic, and continue to do so, it rarely if ever comes out as something that could be packaged and sold on subscription, and when they share it with you they won't have a coupon code.

 

[speculumphilosophi]

I am here advocating for the total disregard of anybody involved in paid occult mentorship.
It's a parasitic industry fueled by social media.

I make this appeal to people who consider themselves students, and those who consider these gurus as peers.
I do not believe that the occult community benefits from this model of growth.

If you are a magician with something to say, write a book, teach people, do as you please; but if you start padding your income with "How to Do Magic" classes, I'm going to regard you as far, far less of a magician than if you weren't offering that. Those who can, do.

"You think everything should be free!"

No. I think people who teach practical magic - who would otherwise be unremarkable as magicians - should be regarded as suspicious at best and more likely as con-men.

"People pay to learn all sorts of things!"

In most fields of human activity, the activity is tangible and the teaching is demonstrable. Nothing like that exists for magic. From an objective point of view there is absolutely no way to tell the difference between who is totally full of crap and who is solid gold in the field of magic.

Sure, learn the history and whatnot, the literature, the tradition, and pay for your academic education in those things. I am not against paying for knowledge.

But occult practitioner gurus are different. They propose to teach something effective, useful, and something for which they profess competence that you could use. So does a martial arts instructor, music instructor, or dance instructor. Pay those people, and anyone can see that something real is being taught. That doesn't exist for magic teachings.

Nobody with better things to do is going to think it's worth their time to sell Zoom classes to goobers from the Internet and then babystep them through whatever they concocted as a babystepping program.

And realize I am not here saying that anything you might get from these gurus is bad or false, although some of it will be for sure. And if you have doubts, for sure, go ahead and pay, and you will see what I mean here. I think the majority of these functions will lead you down a dead-end path, something that was ultimately drafted as a product for sale. That tells you someone got a good sense of the literature and the market for it. But people who connect with real magic, and continue to do so, it rarely if ever comes out as something that could be packaged and sold on subscription, and when they share it with you they won't have a coupon code.

Mostly I agree. I tend to get irritated by the UFO "abductees" or various psychic ghost busters who spin out an income in this way. I believe there have been genuine UFO encounters but so many of the "abductees" or "contactees" or Bigfoot footage filmers come across as very fake. I believe mostly the genuine psychics often tend to be remote outsiders whose gifts cause them their share of unhappiness.

 

[vargr23]

I write books on magic. Years ago, someone tried to convince me to set up some sort of Quantum Sorcery Academy online. They couldn't understand why I didn't like the idea. Just not my thing.

 

[Dyn Hysbys]

I write books on magic. Years ago, someone tried to convince me to set up some sort of Quantum Sorcery Academy online. They couldn't understand why I didn't like the idea. Just not my thing.

I assume people pay you for your books?

 

[Zeeza]

I am here advocating for the total disregard of anybody involved in paid occult mentorship.
It's a parasitic industry fueled by social media.

I make this appeal to people who consider themselves students, and those who consider these gurus as peers.
I do not believe that the occult community benefits from this model of growth.

If you are a magician with something to say, write a book, teach people, do as you please; but if you start padding your income with "How to Do Magic" classes, I'm going to regard you as far, far less of a magician than if you weren't offering that. Those who can, do.

"You think everything should be free!"

No. I think people who teach practical magic - who would otherwise be unremarkable as magicians - should be regarded as suspicious at best and more likely as con-men.

"People pay to learn all sorts of things!"

In most fields of human activity, the activity is tangible and the teaching is demonstrable. Nothing like that exists for magic. From an objective point of view there is absolutely no way to tell the difference between who is totally full of crap and who is solid gold in the field of magic.

Sure, learn the history and whatnot, the literature, the tradition, and pay for your academic education in those things. I am not against paying for knowledge.

But occult practitioner gurus are different. They propose to teach something effective, useful, and something for which they profess competence that you could use. So does a martial arts instructor, music instructor, or dance instructor. Pay those people, and anyone can see that something real is being taught. That doesn't exist for magic teachings.

Nobody with better things to do is going to think it's worth their time to sell Zoom classes to goobers from the Internet and then babystep them through whatever they concocted as a babystepping program.

And realize I am not here saying that anything you might get from these gurus is bad or false, although some of it will be for sure. And if you have doubts, for sure, go ahead and pay, and you will see what I mean here. I think the majority of these functions will lead you down a dead-end path, something that was ultimately drafted as a product for sale. That tells you someone got a good sense of the literature and the market for it. But people who connect with real magic, and continue to do so, it rarely if ever comes out as something that could be packaged and sold on subscription, and when they share it with you they won't have a coupon code.

My thoughts: when you go to the system education - you pay for the mundane knowledge with is based on "indoctrination method statements" to shape you into the being the system wants you to be and where it wants to place you for life long servitude in a capitalistic system which is build on "buy what you want to progress in life" (which to a certain extent is out of your hands). I feel when you look at magical knowledge which is in a sense not of this reality (and i am not talking of fakes) - and also a personal choice to seek a teacher to guide you into the knowledge or principles to enhance yourself on magical or spiritual level it should not be a paid service. If you attend some teaching which require you to purchase a book or material that in itself is payment enough for the teaching lessons. In conclusion maybe if you are not a book writer but teacher, donations is a possibility while all lessons is provided in PDF form form teacher to student and it is on the student to print or not to print.

 

[Faria]

it should not be a paid service.

I'm generally against e-mentoring of whatever type. A person who is willing to make time for you in their real life, and who isn't expecting a check, is probably going to be at least trying to provide you with something worthwhile, assuming they're not a creep. All the online pay-to-learn approaches have a "side hustle" vibe, which to me smacks of primarily commercial intent. Better to sit at the feet of a crazy person in a shack than send Venmo for Zoom lessons, it's a completely different level of personal concern.

Buy a book, and you have a tangible object in your hands. I am specifically here speaking against people who volunteer to be your personal guide for pay, and those who are obviously trying to make a buck by selling classes rather than making a buck by doing something useful with their magic. If they can teach you how to do something useful with your magic, so can they, and if the best they can come up with is teaching you, it's probably a good idea to look elsewhere.

 

[speculumphilosophi]

I am personally O.K. on writing paranormal based books that people can buy. What I oppose is the spin aspect that can latch onto the subject. People who may promote themselves as psychics or private exorsists but are basically the same as TV evangelists.
Recently, I thought about promoting a Latin course exclusively for serious occult students but, as I see it, this is merely a linguistic pursuit, not a lifestyle or cult promotion. When I started learning Latin, I had no major interest in the occult but then discovered how much really valuable material there is in Latin. Such as philosophies, divination, texts on magic stones. It seems to me too that the antiquated, slow, scholary way to.learn Latin is overly complicated and boring. Very serious enthusiasts should consider either Latin, Greek or even an ancient Semitic language. Overall, I think a sensible balance and avoidance of fakery.
There is a word in Latin almost unknown to academics or even serious students. The word is "unguentaria" we can translate as "quackery". This really existed in the Roman world. It promised health and total cures via the use of potions and mixtures, but seemed to do more harm than good. Just like today, people paid out money for these treatments and were enticed.

 

[jakalsa]

I am here advocating for the total disregard of anybody involved in paid occult mentorship.
It's a parasitic industry fueled by social media.

I make this appeal to people who consider themselves students, and those who consider these gurus as peers.
I do not believe that the occult community benefits from this model of growth.

If you are a magician with something to say, write a book, teach people, do as you please; but if you start padding your income with "How to Do Magic" classes, I'm going to regard you as far, far less of a magician than if you weren't offering that. Those who can, do.

"You think everything should be free!"

No. I think people who teach practical magic - who would otherwise be unremarkable as magicians - should be regarded as suspicious at best and more likely as con-men.

"People pay to learn all sorts of things!"

In most fields of human activity, the activity is tangible and the teaching is demonstrable. Nothing like that exists for magic. From an objective point of view there is absolutely no way to tell the difference between who is totally full of crap and who is solid gold in the field of magic.

Sure, learn the history and whatnot, the literature, the tradition, and pay for your academic education in those things. I am not against paying for knowledge.

But occult practitioner gurus are different. They propose to teach something effective, useful, and something for which they profess competence that you could use. So does a martial arts instructor, music instructor, or dance instructor. Pay those people, and anyone can see that something real is being taught. That doesn't exist for magic teachings.

Nobody with better things to do is going to think it's worth their time to sell Zoom classes to goobers from the Internet and then babystep them through whatever they concocted as a babystepping program.

And realize I am not here saying that anything you might get from these gurus is bad or false, although some of it will be for sure. And if you have doubts, for sure, go ahead and pay, and you will see what I mean here. I think the majority of these functions will lead you down a dead-end path, something that was ultimately drafted as a product for sale. That tells you someone got a good sense of the literature and the market for it. But people who connect with real magic, and continue to do so, it rarely if ever comes out as something that could be packaged and sold on subscription, and when they share it with you they won't have a coupon code.

I think there is some merit to paying for very specific magical knowledge, such as the knowledge that you cannot find in books or that must be done orally and require the teacher to do many offering and take time out of their day to do. If a person has become so facetious to sell a class on basic love or prosperity or whosywhatsit magic then I say may they be struck down. But for books, and processes that require expensive and long-winded initiations, I think there is a bit of wiggle room.

 

[Firetree]

I never charged for anything like that , nor did I / do I charge for martial arts instruction . I have seen what happens ; the 'pure system' gets changed to appeal to those that will join up and pay money . It will 'adapt to the market' and eventually degenerate . And in both ( martial and magic ) they can well branch out to selling degrees and levels and fancy costumes , all 'required for success' . My teachers never charged me , so I carry on that tradition .

 

[vargr23]

I assume people pay you for your books?

Sometimes they do. I know that two of them are freely pirated. So it goes. It's not a terribly lucrative vocation, but that's not why I started writing in the first place.