- Joined
- Nov 18, 2024
- Messages
- 430
- Reaction score
- 983
- Awards
- 7
Temporarily De-Centering Greek Paganism and Agnosticism from Goetia
Making another thread to keep from going off topic from here:
Grimoires & PGM - looking for others
wizardforums.com
I know the Greco-Egyptian revival is all the rage right now, thanks largely to Jake Stratton-Kent's excellent work, and it's absolutely valid. But it tends to dominate the conversation to the point where other equally historical approaches get drowned out.
This thread operates under a Chaos Magic framework to explore monotheistic mythic paradigms in grimoire practice. Specifically, we're re-examining and re-inviting the Catholic, Christian, Islamic, and Judaic threads that were historically central to the grimoire tradition afterthe conversions some historians suggest happened during the Byzantine Empire.
While Greek goetia thread is absolutely valid, and I have tremendous respect and adoration for Jake Stratton-Kent's scholarship, there's a case to be made that the contribution of Greek magical papyri to the medieval grimoire tradition may have been somewhat overstated in recent discourse. His PGM-Thelemic framework absolutely works - I've used it successfully myself - but it has contributed to an over-correction toward the "paganization" conversations and threads. This has unfortunately led to increased dismissiveness and hostility toward the monotheistic frameworks that were, if lately, foundational to most of the grimoire texts.
Why Chaos Magic as the Framework. We're using Chaos Magic principles here to maintain methodological flexibility and mutual respect. The paradigm-shifting approach of Chaos Magic allows us to work with Catholic, Islamic, Judaic, or Hermetic henothestic frameworks as functional magical paradigms without requiring literal theological commitment.
What This Thread Is NOT. I'm sorry I even have to say this. This is not the place to: Vent anti-religious sentiment. Relitigate historical grievances against the Church or organized religion. Express atheistic skepticism about theistic practice. Engage in the same tired critiques and propaganda that have been circulating for centuries. Claim the methods of the grims are outdated and pointless becasue your personal buddy Asmodeus told you so.
Also, iIf you find yourself unable to paradigm-shift into a monotheistic mythic framework without experiencing strong negative reactions, this may indicate unresolved religious trauma. That's completely valid and deserves compassionate attention - but here it means, in this particular thread, that this thread may not be the right fit for you right now. Therapy or trauma-specific spaces would be more appropriate venues for that work.
On-topic Discussion Topics
Catholic ritual structure in grimoire work
Exploring Catholic, Christian, Islamic and Jewish othodoxy as it relates to the grimoire tradition
The role of psalms, angelic hierarchies, and divine names
Islamic jinn magic and its relationship to Solomonic tradition
Judaic Kabbalah in grimoire contexts
Hermetic henothestic frameworks
Paradigm-shifting techniques for practitioners from non-monotheistic backgrounds
Practical experiences and results
Spiritualist appraches uch as New World sorcery seance techniques. See Julio Cesar's Ody Magister Officiorum for an example.
A couple to get the grimoire moderate monotheism ball rollin'.
Most people critique Catholicism without knowing what they are critiquing.
Here's Bishop Robert Barron, from Los Angeles, talking about 'God' as the 'Ground of Being', that makes all things luminous.
The Orthodox Catholic version of God is much closer to Neoplatonic conception of The One than the Mean-Cop-in-the-Sky God of other Christianities. This is the language of their internal mystical tradition.
Gitch Bottle's Alexander Eth was raised Catholic, and is supportive of this mythic framework.
Not Just Magicians: Catholic Exorcists Called On Demons, Too
What actually makes exorcisms effective? What are demons? What is the Catholic teaching on magic, grimoires and spirit summoning?
Making another thread to keep from going off topic from here:
Grimoires & PGM - looking for others
Grimoires & PGM - looking for others
I hinted at this in my intro, but I’ll be more explicit here. I’m looking to connect with magicians who work with spirits through the grimoires in a way that stays reasonably close to the textual sources. Most of my background has been in GD and Crowley influenced CM-style work, which was great...
I know the Greco-Egyptian revival is all the rage right now, thanks largely to Jake Stratton-Kent's excellent work, and it's absolutely valid. But it tends to dominate the conversation to the point where other equally historical approaches get drowned out.
This thread operates under a Chaos Magic framework to explore monotheistic mythic paradigms in grimoire practice. Specifically, we're re-examining and re-inviting the Catholic, Christian, Islamic, and Judaic threads that were historically central to the grimoire tradition afterthe conversions some historians suggest happened during the Byzantine Empire.
While Greek goetia thread is absolutely valid, and I have tremendous respect and adoration for Jake Stratton-Kent's scholarship, there's a case to be made that the contribution of Greek magical papyri to the medieval grimoire tradition may have been somewhat overstated in recent discourse. His PGM-Thelemic framework absolutely works - I've used it successfully myself - but it has contributed to an over-correction toward the "paganization" conversations and threads. This has unfortunately led to increased dismissiveness and hostility toward the monotheistic frameworks that were, if lately, foundational to most of the grimoire texts.
Why Chaos Magic as the Framework. We're using Chaos Magic principles here to maintain methodological flexibility and mutual respect. The paradigm-shifting approach of Chaos Magic allows us to work with Catholic, Islamic, Judaic, or Hermetic henothestic frameworks as functional magical paradigms without requiring literal theological commitment.
What This Thread Is NOT. I'm sorry I even have to say this. This is not the place to: Vent anti-religious sentiment. Relitigate historical grievances against the Church or organized religion. Express atheistic skepticism about theistic practice. Engage in the same tired critiques and propaganda that have been circulating for centuries. Claim the methods of the grims are outdated and pointless becasue your personal buddy Asmodeus told you so.
Also, iIf you find yourself unable to paradigm-shift into a monotheistic mythic framework without experiencing strong negative reactions, this may indicate unresolved religious trauma. That's completely valid and deserves compassionate attention - but here it means, in this particular thread, that this thread may not be the right fit for you right now. Therapy or trauma-specific spaces would be more appropriate venues for that work.
On-topic Discussion Topics
Catholic ritual structure in grimoire work
Exploring Catholic, Christian, Islamic and Jewish othodoxy as it relates to the grimoire tradition
The role of psalms, angelic hierarchies, and divine names
Islamic jinn magic and its relationship to Solomonic tradition
Judaic Kabbalah in grimoire contexts
Hermetic henothestic frameworks
Paradigm-shifting techniques for practitioners from non-monotheistic backgrounds
Practical experiences and results
Spiritualist appraches uch as New World sorcery seance techniques. See Julio Cesar's Ody Magister Officiorum for an example.
Post automatically merged:
A couple to get the grimoire moderate monotheism ball rollin'.
Most people critique Catholicism without knowing what they are critiquing.
Here's Bishop Robert Barron, from Los Angeles, talking about 'God' as the 'Ground of Being', that makes all things luminous.
The Orthodox Catholic version of God is much closer to Neoplatonic conception of The One than the Mean-Cop-in-the-Sky God of other Christianities. This is the language of their internal mystical tradition.
Gitch Bottle's Alexander Eth was raised Catholic, and is supportive of this mythic framework.
Not Just Magicians: Catholic Exorcists Called On Demons, Too
What actually makes exorcisms effective? What are demons? What is the Catholic teaching on magic, grimoires and spirit summoning?
Last edited by a moderator: